Grand Cards

Monday, April 6, 2009

If 06 was 09: Left Field

Left field has been a spot of uncertainty for the Tigers for many years. In 2006, Craig Monroe started the majority of games but was supplemented by Marcus Thames. In 2009, it appears as though Marcus Thames and new acquisition Josh Anderson will split time there. One thing is for certain, the Tigers haven't had a stable and commanding presence in Left Field in many, many years.

I will say that Craig Monroe (and to a lesser degree Thames) was an invaluable part of the 2006 team and was as clutch as they come.



It pained me to see the Tigers get rid of him in 2007, because despite his low average and OBP, his power was unreal and he could turn a game upside down with one swing of the bat. Interestingly, Thames is capable of doing the exact same thing, and is almost an exact replica of Monroe, although Monroe is the better defender. Still, the book on 2006 LF is straightforward. Power, acceptable defense, low batting average and little speed. It's the recipe for a 3-run homer and little more.

2009 brought with it a last minute, unexpected change. Carlos Guillen was slated to start the season in Left but a last minute trade brought speedster Josh Anderson over from the Braves.
I expect that he will see many starts in Left, but will Platoon with Thames and perhaps Guillen.



This is a departure from the Tigers recent history. Anderson is a left-handed average and speed guy, not the powerful game-changer and brings a much needed element to a team that got old fast. This does two things: it adds a left-handed bat to the lineup that can put himself in position to score (aka take advantage of the big bats in the lineup) and it keeps Curtis Granderson from having to compromise his outfield positioning to try to help BOTH Guillen and Ordonez at the corner outfield position. Anderson's speed alone vastly improves the outfield defense, because it improves the defense of the Tigers' best outfielder.

The Breakdown:
Defense: 2009
Offense: 2006
Upgrade: Push

Left Field is really a push here. 2005 Monroe/Thames vs. 2006 Monroe/Thames was essentially a wash with power and strikeouts galore. Thames and a bevy of Tigers prospects in 2008 are little different than Thames and Anderson, who is a marginally tested player, at best. Maybe he will work out full-time and maybe he won't. While he certainly adds a new element of speed to the team, he lack of a track record is a liability. Personally, I think that he works out, and if he doesn't Thames can fill in just fine. Either way, Timo Perez is only a call away at AAA if they need him!

If 06 was 09: Catcher

Oh boy. How do you replace a double-digit All Star and future Hall of Famer? You trade him away for local villain Kyle Farnsworth. Oops. But more on that in minute.

In 2006 the Tigers were enjoying their second season of Ivan Rodriguez behind the plate. What can I say, he was a stud.



Pudge took a flyer (and big payday) on the the worst team in baseball before the 2004 season and immediately made an impact. His acquisition was the start of the franchise's turnaround and much of the credit goes to Pudge. Not only was he unbelievably productive both offensively and defensively, but he worked with a very young pitching staff and groomed them for success in the league.

Pudge entered the 2006 season after another All Star campaign and did not disappoint. He earned his All Star designation again in 2006 and continued to play at a consistently high level throughout the season. It is safe to say that the Tigers would have had a very hard time making the playoffs in 2006 without Pudge Rodriguez.

Oh, but alas. Just two short years later, Pudge was playing like a shell of his former self.

His power numbers had disappeared, and he was no longer hitting for average. Now, his seeming inability to take walks--a running joke early in his Detroit tenure--was actually hurting the team. Defensively, he was a shell of his former self. He still has a cannon for an arm, but his feet slowed drastically and more and more balls were bouncing past him. Pudge was an average catcher in 2008 at best. So, he was shipped in a trade that can best be described as "nothing for nothing" as both players were released at the end of the season, with no compensatory draft picks earned on either side. His replacement, Brandon Inge, was an equally poor catcher and left the Tigers with a glaring hole to fill.

Which brings us to today. Gerald Laird, was a starter in Texas who split time with major prospects Jarrod Saltalamacchia and Taylor Teagarden. He was shipped to Detroit to play the position full-time. While there is no way to say that Laird will be better than Pudge from 2006--the catching situation is an unambiguous downgrade from that year--he is almost certainly a major upgrade from 2008.



So that brings us to an interesting breakdown:

Offensive: 2006 Pudge
Defensive: 2006 Pudge
Upgrade: 2009 Laird

Pudge was the better player, hands down. But adding Laird this year will help the Tigers improve over 2008 more than having Pudge in 2006 was. To put it another way, Pudge was not the difference between a last-place 2005 and first-place 2006, he was a constant. Laird's acquisition actually improves the team.

Looking around the infield we find that the 2009 team actually stacks up very well to 2006. The massive upgrade at first base helps make up for the offensive downgrades at Catcher and Shortstop. Defensively, the team may be worse than 2006, but not nearly as bad as they were in 2007 and 2008. In all, I think that the Infield is capable of sustaining a successful team in 2009, not accounting for any major breakouts or drop-offs that may occur.

The verdict: 2006 had a better infield, but 2009 stacks up well and represents a bigger improvement over 2008 than '06 was over '05. In sum, the infield was not the reason for a 2006 World Series run. We'll examine the outfield next.

Sunday, April 5, 2009

If 06 was 09: Third Base



Third Base presents an interesting situation for the Tigers. In 2008, the team started off playing Miguel Cabrera at third base, displacing former Brandon Inge to serve as a backup catcher and super-utility player. This move also pushed Carlos Guillen to first base and the result was a defensive disaster at the corners. A few weeks later, the two flip-flopped and Guillen went to third. The result was an upgrade over Cabrera (interestingly, Cabrera was also an upgrade over Guillen at third) and Carlos was rewarded with the Tigers' only All Star nod. Of course, all of those moves left former starter Brandon Inge wearing catcher's gear and carrying a Gatorade bottle.

Not really the picture you're hoping to see out of your 2009 starting third baseman, but I'll take it. Here's why. Inge is an incredible defensive third basemen, with his only notable weakness of a propensity to throw the ball away when he goes to second. While he is renowned for being a poor hitter, he is actually a significantly better hitter as a third baseman than he is elsewhere in the field. Fantasy owner's take note: Inge will provide his 3B production with Catcher eligibility, FYI.

Of course, we didn't really know all of this about Inge in 2006. He had been a catcher and utility man before being displaced by Ivan Rodriguez. By 2006 he was starting at third again, and seems pretty happy about it:


2006 was a breakout year for Inge, offensively. While he strikes out a lot and doesn't hit for a high average, he has substantial power that creeps up out of nowhere. With 20+ HRs in 2006 he landed a major contract to keep his a third base mainstay, a position he returns to in 2009 after his '08 hiatus. So, how does Inge breakdown?

Offensively: Push
Defensively: Push
Upgrade: 2009 Inge

Here's the deal. Offensively and defensively, there is no reason to expect 2009 Brandon Inge to be any better or worse than 2006 Brandon Inge. I say this under the perspective of Inge before the 2006 season not after the breakout. Certainly, Inge's breakout year on 2006 was a large contributor to the Tigers' success that year. As for an upgrade, Inge is actually a downgrade offensively from Carlos Guillen. However, the defensive improvement is SO LARGE and defense was such a problem for the team in 2008 that it makes up for drop-off in average and increase in strikeouts. To say it another way, 2009 Inge is a bigger improvement over 2008 Guillen than 2006 Inge was expected to be over 2005 Inge. In this sense, the re-addition of Brandon Inge to a third base role will have a major impact on this 2009 team, more so than his role at third had on the worst-to-first season of 2006.

Opening Day Lineup

The Opening Day Lineup was announced today:

CF Curtis Granderson
2B Placido Polanco
RF Magglio OrdoƱez
1B Miguel Cabrera
DH Carlos Guillen
C Gerald Laird
3B Brandon Inge
SS Adam Everett
LF Josh Anderson
P Justin Verlander

There are two things of note:

1. Josh Anderson is starting in Left Field, pushing Guillen to DH
2. Curtis Granderson continues to leadoff, despite rumors that Anderson do so and move Granderson down in the order.

I'm interested to see where Marcus Thames ultimately fits in here, I'm hoping as a part time left-fielder and part-time DH, as this lineup is not so sharp below the 5 spot. I'm not sure that Anderson is suited for a full-time job, so we'll see how this plays out in the first few weeks. Still, there is help from the bench for late inning help, so its not all bad news.

Opening Day tomorrow! Rest of my 2006 vs. 2009 analysis forthcoming in multiple, rapid-fire posts!

Sports and Detroit

An excellent piece by Mike Tirico and ESPN:

Saturday, April 4, 2009

If 06 was 09: Shortstop

With two days until Opening Day, what are the odds that I can complete the roster here? Boy, they sure don't look good, especially because I'll be spending all day today in DC...

In 2006, an injury-plagued infielder with very good offensive numbers and a solid defensive reputation retained his starting job in Detroit:

Guillen went on to have a very good 2006 and solidified the team's defense up the middle. It turns out that his exceptional performance that season was either an aberration or his peak, as his skills markably declined until it was deemed that he should be replaced by Edgar Renteria prior to the 2008 season--a parallel shift at best. Still, heading into 2006 he was regarded to be an above average shortstop on all fronts and played as such.

Enter 2009. The Renteria trade was a disaster, he was a defensive liability and had little offensive impact. Guillen's shift to third, All-Star nod notwithstanding, weakend the left side defense so badly that our sub-par pitching blew up like a Nuclear Bomb. Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you the Answer:

Yes, the defensive wizard Adam Everett, brought on to restore the promise that defense wins championships. While Everett is a light hitter, to say the least, he brings a defensive presence that the team has lacked since 2006 when they led the American League in team defense (not a coincidence that they went to the World Series, I might add). This move is a tremendous upgrade over Edgar Renteria and will go a long way towards avoiding a repeat of 2008.

The Breakdown: (I am removing Continuity for Upgrade. "Upgrade" judges which player is a bigger upgrade over the previous year. In this case, Guillen 2005 vs. Guillen 2006 and Renteria 2008 vs. Everett 2009)

Offense: Guillen 2006
Defense: Everett 2009
Upgrade: Everett 2009

While Guillen 2006 was the overall better player to have on the team, Everett 2009 will help the team improve over 2008 more than Guillen 2006 helped the team improve over 2005. His addition will have a major impact on the team this year and I look forward to seeing him in action. And if he's a bust or gets hurt? There's always Ramon Santiago!

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

If 06 was 09: Second Base

Moving around the infield, let's take a look at second base and compare 2006 to what we've got for Opening Day 2009.

In the second half of 2005 the Tigers traded for Placido Polanco, who proceeded to close out the year on a white-hot tear. So much so, that he would have won the batting title in either league for his overall batting average, but didn't have enough at-bats to qualify in either. With expectations for a solid 2006 season, the Tigers started the year with this:



Who would have guessed that we'd end up with this?



Indeed, Polanco has had an excellent run in Detroit, including a top-3 batting average finish and Gold Glove in 2007 and a very respectable .307 average last year. Moving into 2009, we can see that he's still on top of his game, big head and all:


So, how does Placido Polanco stack up to Placido Polanco? Entering 2009, he has established himself as a consistent hitter and proven asset, much more so than he was in 2006. However, with 3 years behind him, it is unlikely that his defense is where it once was and, apologies to his Gold Glove (which he deserved for his errorless year), his defense has always been above average, but not spectacular. Offensively, what you see is what you get. High average, great with two strikes, little power, little speed. That was the case entering 2006 and appears to remain so today. As a contact hitter, there is no reason to expect any drop-off this year. So,

2006 or 2009?
Continuity: 2009 (3.5 years as starting second sacker under his belt)
Offense: Push
Defense: 2006

I would give the edge to 2006, by a hair. Here's why: Polanco is more of a proven offensive commodity now than he was in 2006 and we expect more of him. However, his actual production is quite similar, its just that Tigers fans are more used to it. On the other hand, any drop off in Defense, however slight, weakens the right side of the infield, especially with a first baseman who has not proven himself with a glove just yet. Still, Polanco remains an anchor on the 2009 team and has a huge impact on the Tigers' ultimate success or failure.

It's all knotted up now at 1 apiece. Shortstop to follow, once I can find a decent baseball card of Adam Everett.